Matthew Schaefer Rookie Commemorative #5

A raw (ungraded) Matthew Schaefer Rookie Commemorative from 2025-26 Topps Now NHL currently carries a market value of about $3. Graded copies sell for more. The value ladder on this page shows the estimated price at each grade.

Across 1 community scans on ZeroPop, the Matthew Schaefer Rookie Commemorative averages a 10.0/10 overall grade. 100% reach Gem Mint (9.5+). Sub-grade averages: corners 10.0, edges 10.0, surface 10.0, centering 9.0.

Whether the Matthew Schaefer Rookie Commemorative is worth submitting depends on its raw value versus its graded value and your predicted grade. ZeroPop scans the card, predicts a PSA/BGS/CGC grade, and runs the break-even math before you pay submission fees.