Skip to content
ZEROPOP
Grading Guides

Pokemon Card Silvering: How Much Hurts a PSA Grade

What silvering on Pokemon cards is, how to spot it, how PSA and Ace grading treat edge whitening, and when a silvered card is still worth the $79.99 fee.

By Marcus Reeves6 min readUpdated Nov 3, 2026
Share

Pokemon Card Silvering: The Edge Flaw That Kills PSA 10s

Silvering is a factory flaw: a thin silver or white line along a Pokemon card's edge where the printed color layer stops short of the cut and the white cardstock core shows. Graders score it as edge whitening, so a visible line usually costs a card its shot at a 10. Hairline silvering can still pass at the top grade, because PSA's published Gem Mint standard tolerates a slight printing imperfection.

That is the short version. Below: what silvering is, how PSA and Ace grading treat it, and which silvered cards are still worth the submission fee.

What Is Silvering on a Pokemon Card?

Silvering is the exposed white core on a card's cut edge. Pokemon cards are printed in layers: a color layer over a white core. If the color layer does not reach the cut, the core shows as a silver or white line, most visibly on dark-bordered cards and on holofoil, where the metallic layer can fall short of the edge.

It is not the same as wear whitening, which builds up from handling and sleeve insertion. Silvering is there from the factory, so you cannot prevent it with better care and nobody can fix it. A grader sees the same white line either way, and the edge subgrade drops either way.

Does Silvering Lower a PSA Grade?

Yes, once it is visible. PSA's published standards, as summarized in a search against its grading standards page this run, say a Gem Mint 10 is nearly flawless but may carry a slight printing imperfection. A Mint 9 may show one minor flaw, such as a minor printing imperfection. Slight fraying at one or two corners appears at NM-MT 8.

PSA does not publish a silvering-specific rule, so the grade ranges below are our reading of that language, not a PSA table:

Silvering you can see Likely PSA outcome Edge subgrade (our estimate)
Hairline, needs a loupe 10 still possible if everything else is clean 9.5 to 10
Light, visible on close inspection Usually a 9 9
Moderate, visible from arm's length on one or more edges 7 or 8 8 or lower
Heavy, continuous around the card 7 or lower 7 or lower

PSA's own page returned a 403 to our fetch this run, so we are relying on a search summary of its wording. Check PSA's standards before you build a submission around one line.

How Ace Grading Treats Silvering

Ace Grading does not mention silvering anywhere on its published grading scale, so no Ace silvering threshold exists to quote. Its scale says edges are scrutinised "for colouration, damage, sharpness and integrity": Grade 10 needs sharp edges, Grade 9 allows a minor edge imperfection, and Grade 8 allows minor whitening on corners, edges or surface.

Two Ace rules matter for a silvered card. It scores surface, centering, edges and corners separately, and says no card gets a total grade more than one grade above its lowest subgrade. Its own example: a 5 on edges caps the card at an Ace 6. Ace also says points of interest and additional observations can lower a grade without changing a subgrade.

So a silvered edge shows up as a visible edge number, the way it does on a CGC or BGS label, and it drags the total down. We could not confirm Ace's pricing this run, so compare fees on Ace's own site.

Free · No account

Grade your first card free.

No account, no download, no waiting. Photograph the front and the back and get the overall grade back in about a minute.

Grade a card free

or get the app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Where Silvering Shows Up

Four spots, in rough order of how often collectors report them:

  • Bottom and right edges. Cutting pressure and sheet alignment tend to expose the core here first.
  • Corners. Two silvered edges meeting can read as corner whitening.
  • Holofoil cards more than non-holo, because the foil layer does not always reach the cut.
  • Dark borders. The same flaw on a pale border can hide until you tilt the card.

Silvering reportedly peaks on 1999 to 2003 Wizards-era cards and shows less on modern ones, but we have no measured rate by set, so check each copy rather than trusting the era.

How to Check a Card for Silvering Before You Submit

Hold the card face up under bright, even light and tilt it so each edge catches the light in turn. Check all four edges and all four corners, front and back, with a loupe for hairlines.

Any white where the printed color should reach the cut is silvering. Note which edges and how visible, then decide using the tiers above. A phone scan helps with the part your eyes miss: an AI grading app such as ZeroPop flags edge whitening and scores the edge axis, though it cannot tell factory silvering from wear, and a phone camera can miss a true hairline that a bench loupe would catch.

What to Do With a Silvered Card

Skip it if the card is under about $150 raw and shows anything beyond a hairline. PSA's cheapest open tier is Regular at $79.99 per card as of our latest sources (the Value tiers were reported paused), and a 9 on a cheap card rarely clears that plus shipping. Our PSA grading cost breakdown has the all-in math.

  • Hairline, otherwise clean: worth a submission if a 10 pays well above the fee. Expect a real chance of a 9.
  • Light silvering: price the card at a 9, not a 10. If a 9 is not profitable, sell it raw. The worth-grading math covers it.
  • Moderate or heavy: sell raw. Never trim or recolor an edge, because altering a card gets it rejected.

Vintage with real value is the exception, since authentication alone can justify the slab.

Silvering vs Edge Whitening: Does the Source Matter?

Not to a grader. They grade the card as it arrives, and the edge subgrade reflects what they see under magnification. It matters to some raw collectors who want a clean-from-pack copy, though the slab market usually does not price the difference.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is silvering on a Pokemon card?

A manufacturing flaw where the printed color layer stops short of the cut edge and exposes the white cardstock core, so a thin silver or white line shows on one or more edges. It is most visible on dark borders and holofoil.

Does silvering lower a PSA grade?

Visible silvering reads as edge whitening and typically costs the card its 10. PSA publishes no silvering rule, but its Gem Mint 10 standard allows a slight printing imperfection, which is why hairline silvering can still earn a 10.

How does Ace Grading treat silvering?

Ace's grading scale does not mention silvering. It scores edges as their own subgrade, allows minor whitening at Grade 8, and caps the total grade at one above the lowest subgrade, so a weak edge pulls the whole card down.

Can a card with silvering still get a PSA 10?

Only if the silvering is hairline and every other axis is clean. If you can see it without magnification, plan on a 9 or lower.

Can silvering be fixed or hidden?

No. Trimming or coloring an edge is alteration, and graders reject altered cards.

Should I buy a silvered card to resell raw?

Yes, if the price reflects it. Raw cards sell on visible condition, so light silvering on an otherwise clean card costs less than it would in a slab. Check the edges against sold listings before you pay.

MR

Written by

Marcus Reeves

Lead Grading Editor, ZeroPop

Marcus has been collecting and grading trading cards since the late 1990s, with a focus on Pokemon, vintage baseball, and modern basketball. He leads ZeroPop's grading research, runs the editorial team's PSA, BGS, and CGC submission tests, and writes the cost and turnaround tracking that powers the app's ROI calculator.

Free · No account

Know your grade before you submit.

ZeroPop scans your cards and gives instant sub-grades for corners, edges, surface, and centering. PSA, BGS, and CGC estimates included. Free to start.

Grade a card free

or get the app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Keep reading